April Meeting - Engineering Ethics

Official ASME Group

Milwaukee Section

A century old, the Milwaukee Section has grown to encompass the southern and eastern reaches of Wisconsin. On offer are open discussions, lively activities, and support for industry and academia...
See More
Edit Post Mode

Enter the date that this post should be published.

Are you sure?

Are you sure you want to delete this file? This action is irreversible.

  • April Meeting - Engineering Ethics

    This month, the ASME Milwaukee Section is going to the Grohmann Museum at the Milwaukee School of Engineering (MSOE) for a presentation on Engineering Ethics by Dr. Jon Borowicz, Associate Professor of Philosophy at the Milwaukee School of Engineering.

    Sociologist Eliot Freidson and philosopher Michael Bayles characterize engineering as a “scholarly” profession as opposed to a “consulting” profession.  Scholarly professions are employed and characteristically affect many clients simultaneously, if the concept of client has application to their practice at all.  Historian Edwin Layton refers to the “engineer’s dilemma” as the “conflict between professional autonomy and bureaucratic loyalty” that is structural to the practice of the great majority of engineers.  The work of scholarly professions is strongly influenced by organizational dynamics.

    We will consider two, or perhaps three, cases which display this effect.  Beginning with the classic case of the space shuttle Challenger, we will consider the controversial supposed shift in the burden of proof with respect to the acceptable temperature for the performance of the solid rocket booster O-rings.  In the Challenger case, the effect was a collective failure to notice the shift in burden of proof.  In two other cases, we will consider the stakes for the integrity of individual engineers for dissenting to a decision which does raise an ethical issue which they recognize.  What happened in the Challenger case will be argued to be the incentive for engaging in activities which cultivate what we might call “moral taste” which enables us to make judgments—to see the ethical matter—when the stakes are high.  Activities designed to cultivate this capacity constituting what might be called the “active” dimension of professional ethics are being incorporated in the ethics course at MSOE.  They will be briefly described.

    Jon Borowicz has been on the MSOE faculty since 1989.  For eight years prior to that he was a systems analyst with Catalyst USA.  Borowicz received the MA and PhD in philosophy from the Johns Hopkins University, and the BA with a major in philosophy from the University of Wisconsin-Madison.  He specializes in professional ethics and the emerging field of philosophical practice, which extends the tradition of philosophy in dialogue and as the cultivation of presence of mind and judgment.  His scholarship makes contributions to both areas.  His presentation/workshop will be concerned with their intersection.

    When registering, you may choose to receive a certificate documenting two Professional Development Hours for attending this presentation, with an additional fee of $5.00.  To receive it, you must register by the April 1, 2014 registration deadline!

    Meeting details:

    • Date:  April 9, 2014
    • Topic:  Engineering Ethics
    • Where:  Grohmann Museum Auditorium at MSOE
    • Time:
      • 5:00 PM Gathering at Grohmann Museum Auditorium at MSOE
      • 5:30 PM Presentation by Dr. Jon Borowicz
      • 6:30 PM Dinner 
      • 7:30 PM Round table discussions and Summative Comments
    • Cost: 
      • Members  $25
      • Non-Members  $30
      • Students & Spouses $15
      • Certificate for 2 PDH's  $5 
    • MENU:  Buffet with
      • Roast Beef with a Cheron Sauce
      • Parmesan Crusted Orange Roughy
      • Parmesan Crusted Red Potatoes
      • Wild Rice
      • Asparagus Spears with Julienne Red Peppers
      • Fresh Summer Blend
      • Tossed Garden Salad
      • Homemade Tortellini Pasta Salad
      • Fresh Fruit Tray
      • Brownies & Assorted Cookies
      • Lemonade, Water and Coffee

    Please register here by the April 1, 2014 Deadline!

Please log in to comment

Comments (0)

Your comment has been posted.   Close
Thank you, your comment requires moderation so it may take a while to appear.   Close
Your avatar